Skip to content
Online marketing

Loyalty programmes and discount codes: What drives repeat purchases

Another order does not necessarily produce a better business result. Giving a discount to someone who would have purchased anyway can leave your store with less contribution. A loyalty programme should start with a reason to return and the economics of the reward. Here is how to connect the offer, rules, customer experience and measurement.

Loyalty programmes and discount codes: What drives repeat purchases

This guide focuses on customers returning over time. Our article on cross-selling and upselling addresses the value of an individual basket. The approaches can work together, but their objectives and costs differ.

01Start with a real reason to buy again

For coffee, the reason may be replenishment; for clothing, another season; for equipment, accessories or servicing. The natural interval depends on the product and customer. Someone who bought a product intended to last several years is not automatically lost because they did not return the following month.

Choose a specific group and obstacle. Customers after their first completed order may not know how to replenish the product, or regular buyers may struggle to find the variant they ordered previously. Check availability, delivery and easy reordering first. A discount cannot fix an unclear offer or repeated poor service.

A customer journey map helps include the period after delivery. Record why returning benefits the customer and what change the business needs. “More club members” is not a sufficient commercial objective on its own.

02Choose a mechanism customers can understand

MechanismWhen to consider itWhat can undermine its value
Next-purchase codeA simple targeted offer after a first orderDiscounting purchases that would happen anyway.
Points earned on purchasesFrequent purchasing with an attainable rewardConfusing conversion rules and a distant reward.
Membership benefitsOngoing service value or convenienceBenefit costs without meaningful use.
Membership tiersDifferent needs among active customersComplex rules and unexpected downgrades.
A decision aid, not a ranking of programme effectiveness.

The reward does not have to be a percentage discount. A useful service, easier reordering or timely availability information may be relevant. Include the actual cost of providing it. Free delivery still costs the business money, and priority service requires real operational capacity.

For points, show what the balance can buy rather than leaving customers to calculate an unfamiliar exchange rate. For an initial test, one mechanism for a clearly defined group is easier to understand than points, tiers, codes and changing exceptions introduced together. Make the reward meaningful without requiring customers to study the programme.

03Calculate how much room the reward really has

Consider an illustrative order excluding VAT: revenue of €50, goods costing €30 and other variable costs of €5 leave a contribution of €15. A 10% discount reduces revenue to €45. With the same costs, contribution falls to €10. In this example, a 10% discount reduces contribution by one third.

Ten original orders generate €150 of contribution. Reaching the same amount requires fifteen discounted orders, or 50% more. This is an authored illustration, not a forecast, client result or net profit calculation. It assumes an unchanged product mix and variable costs, and excludes programme operation, campaign expenditure and fixed costs.

Model: orders needed for the same €150 contribution
  • No discount: €15 contribution per order10
  • 10% discount: €10 contribution per order15

Illustrative model excluding VAT, with unchanged costs and product mix. These are not measured results or a universal required growth rate.

For your own store, include handling, payment fees, subsidised delivery, expected returns and reward costs. Distinguish the contribution percentage of revenue from the discount percentage. A blanket offer may work for one category while making another unprofitable. Revenue alone is an insufficient basis for the decision. A programme can create more activity while leaving less to cover the business.

04Write the rules before writing the promotion

Specify who qualifies, when entitlement begins and how to redeem the reward. Customers need to understand validity, exclusions and combinations before deciding to buy. Promotional copy and the actual checkout configuration must agree. Avoid countdowns or claims of limited availability when the offer simply continues unchanged.

RuleQuestion to resolve before launch
EligibilityWhich order and account create entitlement?
RedemptionWhich products, delivery options and amounts qualify?
CombinationsWhat happens with another discount or points redemption?
ValidityWhen does it begin and end, and in which time zone?
ReturnsHow do earned points and an already-used reward change?
ExceptionsWho corrects a problem and how is the customer informed?
Rules should serve customers, support staff and implementation.

For example, Shopify documents discount combinations by discount class, settings and store eligibility. Do not assume two codes simply add together or that every platform chooses the same outcome. Verify representative baskets and connected apps before communicating the offer.

Designing a club or reworking an unused programme? Send Listify your platform, current rules and intended customer group. We can help align the mechanism, purchase journey and measurement requirements.

Discuss a loyalty programme

05Explain the reward and final price in checkout

The code-entry option should be discoverable without making customers feel they must leave checkout to search for a better deal. After entry, show whether the code was accepted, what it discounted and the final payable amount. If rejected, explain the specific reason: expiry, ineligible items or an incompatible combination.

Test quantity changes, removed products, signing in during checkout and returning from payment. Changes can alter eligibility. Customers must see the current price before confirmation. An invalid code should not require them to discard the basket and begin again. Keep any useful work already completed.

For membership, distinguish the explanation of benefits, necessary account information and communication preferences. The design should reflect the programme terms and applicable data-handling requirements. Make balances, history and a route to support easy to find. The account area is part of the programme experience, not merely an administrative screen.

Five steps from a reason to return through programme rules to contribution measurement
A programme connects customer value, economics, understandable rules and an actual outcome. Issuing a code alone is not the result.

06Plan for returns, duplicate events and support

Awarding points needs a link to the order and a clear confirmation event. Receiving the same event again must not award points twice. For partial returns, specify what happens to the reward earned on the returned item and to a reward the customer has already spent.

Square’s documentation illustrates how point adjustments depend on both programme and refund type. This is an example of differing rules, not a universal recommendation of that platform. Your own implementation needs explicit, verified behaviour for the rules you choose.

When attaching a guest order to an account, verify entitlement. Matching email addresses from different sources do not justify uncontrolled merging. Support needs a traceable history of earning, redemption and corrections. Our article on application payments discusses the connection to refund and order states. Operational staff should be able to resolve a genuine error without silently changing unrelated customer records.

07Measure return behaviour and contribution, not just codes

Track the second completed order, time to return and contribution per customer after rewards and returns. Monitor programme costs and support problems alongside these. A redeemed code proves that an offer was used; it does not tell you whether the purchase would have happened without it.

Compare groups over the same elapsed period from the same starting event. A customer acquired last week has had less opportunity to return than one acquired in spring. Shopify’s cohort analysis follows repeat purchases according to the first-order period. Such reporting describes behaviour, but does not establish what caused it.

Higher spending among members may simply reflect already-active customers choosing to join. To assess a new offer, consider a planned experiment with a comparable control group. Evaluate all assigned customers, not only those redeeming the code. Define the required events in your product analytics. Check identity and refund handling before interpreting apparent improvements.

08Time communication around the customer’s need

Reminders should reflect the purchase and likely need. Suppress a replenishment offer after another order, avoid promoting an unavailable variant and prevent several automations from sending the same incentive. A customer should not receive “come back” messaging immediately after buying again. Operational rules matter as much as the wording.

For apps, design retention push notifications around relevance and preferences. Explain the benefit and lead to the correct product or reward balance. Monitor unsubscribes and communication fatigue too. The volume of messages sent is not evidence that the programme creates value.

09Launch a limited pilot with a defined decision

Choose one group, one offer and an evaluation period that matches the purchase cycle. Agree the budget, owner, contribution safeguards and stopping conditions in advance. Verify checkout, returns, support and reporting before sending the campaign. A promotion should not be the first end-to-end test of the implementation.

After the pilot, decide what to retain, change or stop. Separate limited demand from failures in message delivery or code redemption. For a long purchase cycle, acknowledge when there is not yet enough repeat-purchase evidence. A successful first week may say little about long-term return on the programme.

10Frequently asked questions

Are points better than a discount code?

It depends on purchase frequency, reward value and clarity. Points need a reason for long-term accumulation. A targeted code can be simpler for an initial pilot.

How large should the discount be?

There is no universal percentage. Start with contribution after variable costs, expected use and the offer’s purpose. Include delivery and returns in the calculation.

Does higher member spending prove success?

Not by itself. Members may have been more active before joining. You need comparable groups, equal observation periods and an assessment of programme costs.

Should membership be required to buy?

That is a significant business and UX decision. Weigh its value against the barrier it creates and explain the terms clearly. A loyalty offer does not inherently require mandatory registration.

Can we start without custom development?

Often, existing platform capabilities or a maintained extension can help. Check discount combinations, returns, data exports and operational ownership first. Use custom development to address a real gap.

LISTIFY teamWebsites, apps and marketing from Prague since 2008

More articles

All articles →

Share this page

By email

Got an idea?

On a short call, we'll find out what you need and suggest the next step. Then you'll get a proposal with a fixed price and a timeline.

+420 771 166 199Mon to Fri, 8:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. (Prague time) · info@listify.cool

When should we call you?

Pick a day and a time window. We'll call you, and it takes about 15 minutes.

Day